The Most Common Baking Steel Mistakes (and How to Avoid Them)

1. Not Preheating the Steel Long Enough

Many people assume the steel is ready as soon as the oven reaches temperature. In reality, the steel itself needs time to properly absorb heat.

Fix: Preheat for at least 30–45 minutes at maximum oven temperature.

2. Using Too Much Flour on the Peel

Extra flour can burn on the steel, creating bitter flavours and smoke.

Fix: Use just enough flour for stretching and shake the pizza regularly before launching. Semolina works much better than flour on the peel to prevent dough sticking.

3. Building the Pizza on the Peel for Too Long

Dough will gradually absorb flour and moisture can also seep through, if you build directly on the peel - it can cause the pizza to stick.

Fix: Make your pizza directly on your countertop, then transfer to your peel. Alternatively - stretch the dough first, prepare toppings in advance, then build and launch quickly.

4. Putting the Steel on the Wrong Oven Shelf

A steel positioned too low can burn the base before the toppings cook.

Fix: Start with the steel on the upper-middle shelf and adjust based on your oven.

5. Overloading the Pizza with Toppings

Too many toppings release moisture and prevent proper cooking.

Fix: Less is usually more. Focus on balance rather than quantity.

6. Using Cold Dough Straight from the Fridge

Cold dough is difficult to stretch and often bakes unevenly.

Fix: Allow dough balls to come close to room temperature before stretching.

7. Not Using the Grill/Broiler Effectively

A baking steel cooks the bottom quickly, but many home ovens struggle to brown the top.

Fix: Use the grill during the final minute or two if your oven allows it safely.

8. Launching with Hesitation

A slow launch often results in misshapen pizzas and toppings everywhere.

Fix: Use a confident, quick forward-and-back motion and a flick of the wrist. Wiggle/shake if you're not comfortable with a super-fast launch.

9. Choosing the Wrong Cheese

Fresh mozzarella contains a lot of moisture and can create puddles of liquid.

Fix: Drain fresh mozzarella thoroughly or use low-moisture mozzarella. Even better - use fior di latte mozzarella as it leaks little to no moisture.

10. Neglecting Steel Maintenance

While baking steels are durable, they can rust if left wet after cleaning or spills.

Fix: Dry thoroughly after cleaning, then apply oil and bake for 1 hour. Maintain an additional light seasoning layer when needed.

Final Thoughts

A baking steel is one of the best upgrades for home pizza makers, but it isn’t completely foolproof. Most disappointing results come down to heat management, dough preparation, or launching technique rather than the steel itself. Master these fundamentals and you’ll be producing pizzeria-quality pizzas from a standard home oven.

Your steel comes pre-seasoned with UK beeswax, but it needs some tlc from time to time. Learn how to properly care for your purchase.